exactly
I got a lot of TDH in szn 11 and got to mint a cool ACK nft in szn 12
Shit Punk Says
Oceans of Wisdom
19,158
matching drops
#1459158
2026-09-22 15:17
benefit more by getting more people in obviously
the OGs/whales
yes that is what i think too
I think the boost does need to cap. I actually like this personally. From a collector, buyer/seller behavior that i've witnessed, having a reason for new collectors to want newer sets is actually good. those are the ones we want to continue having mint demand, and buy demand as they do not have as much accumulated TDH on them. This is not that important for those of us that never really plan to sell any cards, but for the group that may want to buy/sell/trade a card, it is better i think.
or it could be
might be better
not hard drop-off
now we could make it exponentially smoothed
is to give new minters a leg up to get somewhere with TDH
just do the obvious ones!
too giga brained for me to think of things outside of the obvious things?
is to give new minters a leg up to get somewhere with TDH
idea behind giving a temp boost to the new sets
every set becomes a >1 year old set
and eventually
it is going to have to drop at some point
unless we want boost to grow indefinitely
So i guess the question is, does dropping the season set bonus on seasons > 1 year old discourage people from collecting those seasons?
sorry 0.75, not 0.80
Or the remaining 0.75 i guess
there can't be collector specific changes otherwise you open up gaming again
1st and last 4 in chrono are 0.05 and then the rest split up the remaining 0.80
it has to do with how many exist
it has nothing to do with how many you have collected
I don't think the fact that I know the boost will drop off some in a year effect me from collecting new seasons, so it seems fine. but also. if you have collected < 20 seasons doesn't that mean the set bonus for each stays at .05 until you are greater than 20 seasons?
and obviously a cost
no benefit to splitting
So when we have 40 SZNs (year 10):
- SZNs 40, 39, 38, 37, 1 accrue at 0.05 (for everyone)
- SZNs 2 to 36 accrue at 0.75/35 = 0.021"
it is dropping systemwide
it will drop whether you split them off or not
In regards to the larger TDH discussion around season set bonuses, I mean I think I prefer Punk's original proposal the best. Yes, the set bonus would drop for older seasons after you have held them 1 year, but the accumulated TDH on those would completely discourage splitting them off at that point. It seems like a nice way to incentivize new collectors and Old collectors to continue collecting new seasons, while having a cap.
but more than that, our future is here
i think it is now a vulnerability bc not being watched
i have not gone in months
Is there anything still happening on discord? I see no usecase
it makes it very clear what the problem is
just go design other AL mechanisms and try to hack them :)
i am admittedly not an anti-Sybil expert but I understand that is a key goal here
sure, but that in and of itself does not matter (novelty)
to understand this discussion, you should think carefully about why TDH is like this for every other case except this fringe edge case
I agree, TDH is potentially novel. it’s for sure a reason I’m here
it is just a convenient one to start with in the NFT space
it is a minor issue within a class of important issues
is not some minor issue
and "how to fairly allocate an allowlist spot"
is worse than TDH
except TDH
literally every AL allocation I have seen in the NFT space
and you then have no idea that actual nature of your society
to increase their chances
so of course you incent people to create sock puppet accounts
is what most people do
"lottery among all holders of cards"
"you have 300 valuable allowlist spots. how do you allocate them"
imagine it very simply as follows
it is the whole principle of TDH
in principle
well it is not fringe
this is the point of TDH
of course